Jewelry Selling? Here's How to do it Safely!

Do you have jewelry that you no longer wear or don't like? Are you looking for a way to turn your unwanted jewelry into cash? Selling your unwanted jewelry is a great way to make some extra money and clear out unwanted clutter. 

This guide will help you to understand the process of selling your unwanted jewelry, including how to evaluate the value of your pieces, tips on pricing, and advice on where to sell it safely. With the right approach, you can make a good return on your jewelry and free up some extra space in your home.

Related: Jewelry That You’ll Always Love to Wear

What are the Reasons that People Sell their Jewelry?

People often sell unwanted jewelry for a variety of reasons. One of the most common reasons is to make some extra money. Whether it's for a special occasion or simply to have some extra cash, selling jewelry is a great way to turn unwanted pieces into cash. 

Related: Replica Jewelry: How to Spot Popular Fakes

Another common reason for selling jewelry is to trade it in for something else. This could be trading in old jewelry for new pieces or for something completely different such as furniture or electronics.

People also sell jewelry to reduce clutter. People often find themselves with jewelry that they simply don't wear anymore. Selling jewelry is a great way to clear out clutter and make room for more meaningful pieces.

Finally, some people sell jewelry to help others. Many people sell jewelry they no longer want to charity organizations or to those who need it more. This is a great way to give back to the community and make a difference in someone else's life.

No matter the reason, selling jewelry is a great way to make some extra money, reduce clutter, and help others.

Are you looking for jewelry you’ll never want to sell? Take a look at our new arrivals!

Where Do I Sell My Unwanted Jewelry?

Now that you’ve picked out a few pieces of jewelry that you want to sell, you have to decide where and who to sell to. Here are a few of the most popular options for selling your used jewelry:


eBay is an international online auction website with a massive number of users all around the world. Buyers can browse goods that are for sale, in this case, your unwanted jewelry, and can bid on it.

One of the main advantages of using eBay to sell your used jewelry is that eBay is the world’s largest online marketplace for third-party sellers. If you have had difficulty selling your items, eBay will probably have a buyer for them.

Family, Friends, and Acquaintances 

If someone you know personally has admired the piece that you are trying to sell, there is a good chance that they might be willing to buy it from you. Just figure out what price you both agree is fair and make the exchange. Think of it as keeping the jewelry in the family.

An advantage of selling to people that you already know is that once you both agree, the exchange can be done instantly. Also, selling your unwanted jewelry to friends and family will usually give you a better price than a pawn shop or stranger would.

Pawn Shop

A pawn shop is a business where people can take items such as jewelry, electronics, musical instruments, and other items as collateral for a short-term loan. The pawn shop then pays the customer a cash loan and keeps the item until the loan is repaid. If the loan is not repaid, the item is sold to recoup the loaned money.

The advantage of selling to a pawn shop is that you can get quick cash. There are pawn shops in every city in the United States, so they won’t be hard to find. Unfortunately, most pawn shops will only give you the loan amount for your jewelry instead of a fair sale amount.

Ready to replace some of the jewelry you sold? Take a look at our best sellers!

Tips on Keeping Your Jewelry and Yourself Safe

If you are meeting somewhere to make the exchange, make sure you plan it in a safe and public place. Meet inside a bank, at a major store, or in front of a police station to make sure that you are safe.

After you make the exchange in person, make sure that you aren’t followed home. Depending on the amount of the sale, you may want to have the exchange done at your bank where you can quickly deposit it safely afterward.

Never meet someone that you do not know at your home. It may be more convenient, but take the time to meet at a public place. Your safety is much more important than convenience.

Use a secure payment processor: It’s essential to use a secure payment processor when selling jewelry online. Look for one that uses SSL encryption technology, which ensures that all customer information is encrypted and secure.

If you are mailing your jewelry to the buyer, use a secure shipping method. When shipping jewelry, make sure to use a secure shipping option. You can opt for services such as FedEx or UPS that offer tracking and insurance for the package.

Require signature upon delivery: Require customers to sign for their package upon delivery. This will ensure that the jewelry is delivered to the customer and that you have proof of delivery.

Include insurance: Make sure to include insurance in the shipping cost so that customers can be reimbursed if their package is damaged or lost in transit.

Related: How to Insure Jewelry

Stay informed on scams: Be aware of any potential scams that may target jewelry buyers. Research any red flags or suspicious activity, and look out for signs of fraudulent behavior.